mental illness is bunkum


I used to live at a hostel which presumably, was for vulnerable young people. I lost the place when I got arrested however, I still see a couple of the girls from there. Recently, I learnt that one of these girls had bi-polar disorder, which really illustrated how sudden mental illnesses are, and how no-one is immune … sorry, I can’t do it. I can’t write this crap. I really can’t endorse “sentimental stupidity”, or “sympathetic silliness.” Mental illness is bunkum.

I’ve instinctively “sensed” this for much of my life. I just couldn’t buy into it. There was always a somewhat dubious quality about the whole controversy. Perhaps it’s because I was always intrigued by language; so naturally, I would be suspicious of any language constructs, which is what mental illness is: a linguistic deception. I would like to outline the fundamental tenets of my numerous essays examining this popular fiction, and yet, this being a blog, I think it would be better for me to treat you to the basic premises that underpin the challenge to “mental illness fans.”

Psychiatry/Mental Illness is a joke that people have taken seriously. Mental illness is an attempt to explain the unknown; it is a God of the Gaps. Someone is “experiencing” psychological distress, or feels themselves to be mentally disturbed, and so, after visiting their doctor, is diagnosed as “ill”/”unwell.” Firstly, how are we to measure “health?” Is a “healthy” person “normal?” When we are young, do we not mostly ask “what is normal?” It is what the majority is perceived to consistently be doing, but what does this mean?

It means nothing and can not mean anything. Even if there were a “universal average” derived from the common people, what would be the significance of this finding? What would be the justification for “extrapolating” this amazing revelation? There still would be no meaning to this approach. It does not follow. Even if you find a standard, there is nothing demanding individuals conform to the standard… What do I mean…? I mean that psychiatry is a joke, meaning: mental illness is bunk!

“…[being] behaviour that other people dislike …there is no mental illness; there is no psychiatric diagnosis; there is no psychiatric treatment. These are all words; words used by more powerful people against less powerful people in the name of helping them [but] actually control them or punish them or both… I call it the therapeutic State.”

About omalone1

I live I die I write
This entry was posted in Competent Commentaries and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s